He accidentaly __________ a glass of water on the table.
a. spilt
b. threw
c. poured
d. splashed
above was the 3rd question in the recent UPSR paper 1. First look at it, I'd say the answer would be "a" with the reasons being; it's an accidental act and the water was in a container (glass is a kind of container right?).
So like half hour ago my head of department gave me a copy of both paper 1 and 2-if I wanted my year 5s to try them. A colleague looked at it and asked me the answers for the questions. So when I said that the 3rd question's answer was "a", my head of department said that she heard from teachers from other school, who referred to someone they called "an expert teacher" that the answer is "d".
So the arguement started.
I did ask Gruffy which one was the right one when I finished invigilating exam last week cos I saw tons of kids chose "d. splashed" instead of "a.spilt". He said he'd used them both before but thought "a." was a more accurate answer.
Like I mentioned above, I was 100% sure, I still am sure that the answer is "spilt" because it's an accidental act and that the water was in a glass. Gruffy also said that you don't "splash" water in glass. Honestly, I never really used the word "splashed" before for accidental events like drinks spilling on the table. To me it's a word that I would use when someone really does "splashing water" act to me.
ok, clearly I am not your excellent English teacher...whatmore an expert. But below are the definitions I got from Oxford online and I am gonna submit an inquiry about this - there's no way I'm letting this go easily, I want a legit answer so I don't teach my kids the wrong thing!
spill1
• verb (past and past part. spilt or spilled) 1 flow or cause to flow over the edge of a container. 2 move or empty out from a place. 3 informal reveal (confidential information).
splash
• verb 1 (with reference to a liquid) fall or cause to fall in scattered drops. 2 make wet or cover with scattered drops. 3 strike or move around in water, causing it to fly about. 4 (splash down) (of a spacecraft) land on water. 5 display (a story or photograph) in a prominent place in a newspaper or magazine. 6 (splash out) Brit. informal spend money freely.
• verb 1 (with reference to a liquid) fall or cause to fall in scattered drops. 2 make wet or cover with scattered drops. 3 strike or move around in water, causing it to fly about. 4 (splash down) (of a spacecraft) land on water. 5 display (a story or photograph) in a prominent place in a newspaper or magazine. 6 (splash out) Brit. informal spend money freely.
care to explain?



